Annie Archer and her stepbrother Tony Lovelock don't have much in common. In fact, they're at each other's throats pretty much all the time. The only thing they can agree on is how much they hate doing chores. As they're in the kitchen together, Annie begins humming a tune that Tony identifies as the My Family Pies theme. The stepsiblings are each surprised that the other knows that site. This new comradery leads Tony to ask why Annie has been so rude to him, like pantsing him in front of her friends. Annie gets sassy about it, so Tony splashes her, which turns her white tank top sheer. Annie is shocked and pissed, but she handles it by just taking her shot off and telling Tony that he can deal with it. Tony tries to keep his eyes of his stepsister's tits, but then she starts in on the My Family Pies song again. It's too much for Tony, who pops a boner. When Tony accidentally pokes Annie with his erection, the stepsiblings get into it again before they each just go back to their rooms.

A while later, Annie realizes that she's still super turned on by the thought of her stepbro in the My Family Pies sense. Still topless, she goes to where Tony is in his room, looking guilty and sad. When Annie accuses Tony of making her nipples hard, he shoots back that she made his dick hard. Tony is sick of Annie's shit as he tells her off, and after a second, Annie tells Tony he should in fact fuck her. He's in shock as Annie reaches out to wrap her hand around his fuck rod and then leans in to start sucking him off. Who would turn down a busty blonde giving him a blowjob? Not Tony.

When Annie peels off her shorts and thong, Tony helps guide her down onto his erection so she can ride him in cowgirl and then reverse cowgirl. Her ass provides the perfect grip for Tony's hands as she bounces away on the D. Getting on her hands and knees, Annie offers herself to Tony for a doggy style pussy pounding that he is happy to deliver. When Annie rolls onto her back and starts begging Tony for a creampie, he delivers with a big nut. Dripping with her stepbrother's cum, Annie resumes humming the theme song from My Family Pies.