Vanessa Sky and her friend Kylie Rocket are having an argument over a guy right in front of Vanessa's stepbrother, Tony. The argument devolves into which of them is hotter. When the girls start shoving, Tony intervenes. Eventually the girls insist that Tony settle the dispute of who has a fatter ass. They turn around and pop their asses out. Tony tries to retreat to his room, but the girls follow him to his room and insist that Tony helps them figure out who sucks better dick. They want Tony to judge. He lays down some stipulations, but eventually agrees.

Pulling his pants off, Tony pulls out his hardon. Kylie starts since she's so confident, but the girls take turns so he can judge properly. They deliver a double BJ, but Tony can't decide who is better. The only thing the girls can think of when Tony can't decide about the better blowjob is that he has to say who has the better pussy. The only way to achieve that is by fucking them both. Tony agrees to help settle the debate. The girls peel off their clothes and get on their knees side by side to present a proper pussy buffet for Tony's inspection.

Tony sinks balls deep into Kylie's snatch first as Vanessa suckles Kylie's nipples. Vanessa gets her turn next as Tony gives it to his stepsis. As Vanessa's pussy is quivering from her climax, Kylie gets on her hands and knees so Tony can bang her in doggy while she eats Vanessa out. Vanessa gets another spin on her stepbro's hardon as she rides him in reverse cowgirl. At the end, the girls work together to get Tony off since he has pleasured them both so deeply. He nuts into Vanessa's mouth so she can snowball her salty treat with Kylie. At the end, Tony claims he can't pick and they'll have to try again so he can choose a winner.