Jazmin Luv and her BFF Alicia Williams are having some fun on their phones. Jazmin asks Alecia what she's up to, and Alecia explains that she's taking pictures for her social media because her ass looks amazing in those shorts. Jazmin points out that those are her shorts and that her booty looks way better in them. The girls start arguing over whose boobs and butt are better, but when they can't settle it between themselves they decide to seek an expert opinion. Jazmin's stepbrother, Quinton James, is the easiest guy for them to ask, so they barge on into his room.

Quinton was mid-masturbation when the girls came in, but he manages to hide it fast enough. Jazmin and Alicia confront Quinton and demand that he tell them which one has a better ass. He eventually says it's Jazmin, but not by much. The girls then need to know who has better tits. Alicia takes the opportunity to pull up her shirt and let her cute titties pop out. Jazmin is surprised, but she's not about to let Alicia win by default so off comes her shirt, too. Quinton claims he still can't judge properly without feeling them, so they each let him cop a feel. The competition then extends to has the better pussy, then to who can give the better blow job with Quinton as the only judge.

When the girls decide to see who can fuck Quinton better, he's happy to keep letting them compete. Jazmin gets the first shot at riding her stepbrother's hardon, but Alicia is right behind her to take over. Jazmin comes back onto Quinton's cock for a reverse cowgirl ride, but then tags out once again with Alicia. Alicia keeps getting her pussy pounded on her back as she feasts on Jazmin's snatch. When the girls trade spots again, with Jazmin on her back enjoying Quinton's dick and Alicia riding Jazmin's mouth, they keep it up until they're both nearly sated. Jazmin turns around so that her face is beneath Quinton's balls, as Alicia covers her in a lesbian 69 with Quinton doing her in doggy. That position lets Quinton get close to cumming, so that he can pull out and nut into Jazmin's open mouth. The girls exchange a kiss to swap the jizz, knowing that they're both more than hot enough.