Lauren Phillips and her stepdaughter Lilly Bell have a nice new neighbor, Tyler Nixon. Tyler helps Lauren bring in the groceries, which prompts Lauren to say that he should meet Lilly since they're about the same age. Lauren goes to get Lilly, who reminds her stepmom that she already has a boyfriend. When Lauren is skeptical, Lilly confesses that her boyfriend in an asshole, but she stays with him because he has a nice dick. Lauren suggests that Lilly should come check out Tyler's cock and see if that's nice, too. Lilly agrees that if Tyler's fuck stick is nicer than her boyfriend's, she'll give him a chance.

Leading Tyler into the living room, Lauren eventually coaxes him into whipping his dick out. When Lilly sees it, she's pretty properly impressed. So is Lauren, who can't help but get down on her knees and start sucking Tyler off. Mommy redhead is happy to share with Lilly since that's her whole goal, so soon enough the girls are working together to deliver a sloppy double BJ. Then Lauren hops onto the couch so that Lilly can eat her mama out as she gets her pussy pounded by Tyler from behind. It turns out that Tyler has a very nice cock indeed, so nice that Lauren simply must take it for a spin of her own as Lilly rides Lauren's mouth.

Seating Tyler on the couch, Lauren helps Lilly up to ride his dick. Lilly's trimmed snatch is nice and wet as she rides him hard and fast with Lauren lapping at her tender nipples. Then Lilly gets on her knees and goes back to feasting on Lauren's snatch as Tyler bangs her in doggy until he pops all over her ass. Since Tyler is still hard, Lauren takes a spin of her own, burying Tyler's face between her big boobies as she rides him. He has another climax ready to go when he pulls out to blast off all over Lauren's big butt. Since Tyler can do two orgasms to the one that Lilly's asshole boyfriend is capable of, Lilly decides to give him a chance after all.