Callie Jacobs and her stepbrother Jay Romero have gotten together in the biblical sense before, but Callie is prickly about when and where Jay can fuck her. When Jay comes into her room and starts creeping on her, Callie isn't in the mood. Later, though, Callie puts on a short miniskirt and a bright red thong. When Jay comes in and asks what she's doing, she makes sure he gets a good look at all the goods before she tells Jay she thinks that she lost her phone under the couch. When Jay gets on his knees to look, Callie hops onto the couch and pulls her thong aside, telling him that he can lick her pussy. Although Jay is hesitant, he isn't about to pass up the offer of that bald puss.

Leaning in, Jay slips his tongue between Callie's slick folds. He laps away at her soft warmth, giving his fingers a workout in her tight twat. When Jay gets to his feet and whips out his hardon, though, Callie sends him away. Jay is confused, but he's right where Callie wants him. Still later, Jay pops into Callie's room to let her know that her mom wants her for something and Callie lays it out there that she wants to fuck him. She's not wearing anything beneath her miniskirt, and when she pushes her confused stepbrother he capitulates almost immediately. Her only request is that Jay doesn't cum inside her. He agrees and then shoves himself in to ride Callie as he twists her hard nipples.

Callie throws herself into their lovemaking, letting her head fall back as she moans long and loud. She pushes Jay onto the bed and sucks her own juices off his hardon before she climbs on top of him and sinks down. Jay's dick in her tight snatch feels just incredible in both cowgirl and reverse cowgirl. When Callie gets on her knees for some doggy style, she can't hide her moans of pleasure. She's still enjoying the afterglow when Jay pops his load inside her. When she realizes what her stepbro has done, Callie kicks Jay out of her room even as his creampie keeps dripping from her fuck hole.