Jessie Saint and her friend Kyler Quinn don't have valentines, but they want to do something nice for someone. They decide to make Valentine's Day cards for Jessie's stepbrother, Codey Steele. Codey accepts the girls' cards, but he misinterprets their intentions. While Jessie and Kyler were just trying to be sweet, Codey took it as a comeon. He returns to give them a gift: a goodie bag complete with his dick in the bottom. Kyler is the first to take treats out of the bag, but when she reaches the D she tells Jessie that she thinks that's for her. When Jessie discovers what's in the bag, she freaks out and takes off.

Later, when Kyler and Jessie try to talk out what happen, Jessie admits that she feels badly about her reaction. She's a lot more into Kyler than her stepbrother, but she's game to change into lingerie with Kyler and call Codey into her room so they can apologize. When Codey arrives, Kyler reaches out to pop his hardon from his shorts. As Kyler is on her knees sucking Codey off, Jessie comes up behind her to tug her thong off and eat her out.

Turning around, Kyler wiggles her ass to invite Codey to plunge balls deep into her from behind. Meanwhile, Kyler sinks her face into Kyler's puss for a musky feast. She brings Jessie off moaning, then helps her friend climb onto Codey's fuck stick. Once Jessie is settled, Kyler hops onto Codey's mouth to ride his tongue as Jessie rides his dick. The girls swap spots, with Kyler riding Codey in reverse cowgirl while Jessie plants her pussy on his face. They end with Codey fuckin Jessie until he' about ready to blow his load. Codey pushes deep as he reaches the end of his endurance, glutting his stepsis with a creampie of hot jizz.