It's Christmas time and Jay Romero and his stepsister Alicia Williams are taking the time to flirt while they decorate the tree. They're stopped by doing anything more when Alicia's mom, Crimson Morning Star, walks in and breaks it up. She pulls Alicia aside and tells her to cut it out because Jay is special. After insisting that Alicia cut out the flirting, Crimson suggests that Jay and Alicia make some gingerbread houses. They're just getting started when Crimson reappears with Celestina Blooms, the next door neighbor. Celestina is Crimson's insurance policy that Alicia won't get frisky with her new stepbro.

Crimson's gamble backfires. Alicia doesn't care about Celestina. She flashes her firm titties at Jay despite Celestina's presence. Smearing frosting on her nipple and spreading her thighs to hike up her miniskirt. Celestina eventually notices and tries to call Alicia out, but she explains that she has a fantasy about falling in love on Christmas. While Celestina is agreeing that Alicia's fantasy is indeed hot, Jay is busy popping out his hardon and sticking it into his gingerbread house. He shows the girls that he has decorated the inside of his gingerbread house, too, but Crimson walks in before he can take his cock out of the house. Fortunately for all three of them, Crimson doesn't have her glasses and doesn't notice the D. When Crimson takes off again, Alicia can't wait another moment: She breaks the house open and then gets down to start sucking Jay's dick. Celestina finds it super hot, so after rubbing her own titties for a bit she asks to join in on the fun. Alicia is happy to share!

The girls eventually take their BJ to the couch, where Jay gets on his back so Alicia can hike up her short skirt and climb aboard. Again, Celestina watches for a bit until she's too hot and bothered to sit it out. She is brought in to the fun with a doggy style pussy pounding as she muffles her moans by feasting on Alicia's cream filled fuck hole. Rolling onto her back, Celestina gasps and moans as Jay pounds her bare twat while Alicia masturbates behind her. The girls switch spots, with Alicia cradling her stepbro between her thighs and Celestina fondling Alicia's nipples. Once he has his stepsister twitching, Jay can't wait another minute to cum. Without bothering to pull out, Jay busts a nut into Alicia's cum loving fuck hole. Celestina is now certain she wants to hang out with Alicia and Jay more often. She doesn't skip a beat before getting down on her knees to lap up the creampie and share her treat with Alicia.