Chloe Temple, Madison Summers, and Scarlet Skies are inseparable BFFs. Today the girls are getting Madison's house all ready for Easter by decorating. The only catch to hanging out at Madison's place is that her stepbrother, Codey Steele, is kind of a perv. When he starts up with the girls today, Madison decides to start flirting right back. Eventually Codey has had enough and takes off, at which point Chloe and Scarlet start questioning Madison about what she was doing. Does Madison want to fuck her stepbrother? When her friends put it like that, Madison realizes that's exactly what she wants to do. Scarlet is a little weirded out by it, but Chloe is totally into it and thinks that the idea is really hot.

Later that day, the girls continue to get into the Easter spirit by dressing up as sexy bunnies. They corner Codey and give him a lesson about the meaning of Easter. They explain that the bunny is associated with Easter to symbolize fertility. Once the girls have delivered their spiel. Madison sits on the couch beside Codey and pulls her teddy bottom aside to expose her pussy as she informs Codey that all this means he needs to get her pregnant. Codey isn't sure what to say at first, so Chloe goes to help. She pulls Codey's hardon out to start sucking him off alongside Madison. Scarlet isn't sure about this at first, but watching her friends suck the D is so hot that she realizes she totally wants to join in and be part of an epic Easter foursome.

Since it was Madison's idea to get with her stepbrother, she gets the first go with his cock. She climbs on and rides Codey in reverse cowgirl as her friends cheer her on. Chloe gets her turn next as Codey fucks her in doggy. Meanwhile, Madison moans in delight as Scarlet feasts on her pussy. Scarlet's first go with Codey is on her back as Chloe and Madison each kneel nearby to caress and stroke Scarlet for added pleasure. Madison swaps spots with Scarlet to spread her thighs for Codye once again. Madison initially cradles Scarlet's head in her lap, but eventually she adjusts her position to ride Madison's tongue as Codey fucks his stepsis to a big creampie. Pleased that Codey has delivered on their Easter pregnancy request, Madison and her friends sample the dripping cum as they bask in the afterglow.