Xxlayna Marie goes to her stepbrother Jay Romero's room to tell him that the friend that's been coming over all the time recently has a huge crush on him. Xxlayna goes on to tell Jay that her friend, Gracie Gates, has an incurable disease. It's not contagious, but Gracie really wants Jay to fuck her. Jay agrees, then learns that Gracie has been waiting right outside the door. Just as Gracie comes in for a kiss, Xxlayna yells PSYCH and dissolves into laughter.

Jay is understandably taken aback by the prank, but Gracie looks up at him and announces that she wasn't joking; she really has had a crush on Jay for a long time. Over the squeals of Xxlayna's protests, Gracie lays back, peels her shorts off, and spreads her thighs so that Jay can slide her underwear aside and sink balls deep into her tight twat. Xxlayna's protests eventually peter out as she realizes how hot it is to watch her BFF fuck her stepbrother. In fact, she can't help but rub her own pussy. When she's invited by Gracie to join in, Xxlayna climbs onto her friend's face to let Gracie lap at her clit as Jay continues to fuck her.

The impromptu threesome kicks off completely as Xxlayna gets on her hands and knees so Jay can enter her from behind. Meanwhile, Gracie takes a seat in front of Xxlayna so that her friend can trace her fingertip down the wetness of Gracie's wet slit. The girls take a few minutes to enjoy a double blowjob as they work together to make Jay's day with their hot little hands and mouths. Then Gracie takes advantage of Jay's position on his back to climb aboard and ride him in cowgirl. She knows it's important to Xxlayna to have the last ride, so Gracie climbs of the D and helps her bestie climb on for a reverse cowgirl delight that leaves her moaning. Jay pulls out just in time to blow his load all over Gracie's belly.