Molly Little has invited her friends Dakota Tyler and Maya Woulfe over to help decorate for a Christmas fundraiser event. Dressed as slutty reindeer, the girls bounce and giggle as they put the finishing touches on Santa's Workshop. Molly's stepdad, Charles Dera, comes in to compliment them on what a good job they've done. The girls invite Charles to dress up as a reindeer, too, but he points out that his son already agreed. Molly says that her stepbrother is a creep who will probably try to grab on them, and Charles responds he'd do the same thing if he wasn't her stepdad.

Molly tells her stepdaddy she'd love to feel her legs quivering from his dick. Charles takes that to heart and returns wearing a reindeer costume. The girls can't tell who's in the reindeer suit, so Molly and Maya pull their tits out to see what happens while Dakota watches uncertainly. As Molly pulls out the reindeer's wood, Dakota puts out there that people will be arriving soon. Molly and Maya don't care; they go for a BJ. Dakota can't resist any longer. She starts by lifting her miniskirt to masturbate, then joins on in.

After a triple BJ, Molly gets on her knees to eat out Dakota while her stepdaddy pounds that pussy and Maya lets Dakota diddle her. Maya gets her turn with Charles's cock as she lays on her back with Dakota riding her face and Charles between her thighs. Meanwhile, it's Molly's turn to watch and masturbate. When Dakota climbs on top of Charles's fuck stick and begins bouncing away on him in cowgirl while Molly lets her stepdaddy eat her pussy out. Charles is just about ready to blow his load, so Molly gets on top of him and rides him in reverse cowgirl to a creampie that she shares with her BFFs.